2. digital
  3. 1275154822

Anyone Use A CD Recorder For Main Play Back?

Is this audio blasphemy? My Marantz Sa-14 is still down as I wait to see if the part pointed out to me by another member will work. In the meantime I have been using my CD recorder for play back. It's a Marantz Professional CDR-500 and I'm shocked how good it sounds. I'm wondering if I should put the SA-14 (TRL modified) up for sale! Most likely I've forgotten how great the SA-14 really is and yes it sounds better but frankly I think I could live with what I have now. Am I nuts? Does anyone have a similar experience? Anyone have this player? I'll look forward to responses. Thanks.
zar
10 responses Add your response
slikric3000
638 posts
 
I used a Pioneer PDR-19RW while mah DV-AX10 was in for repair, fed it into a Counterpoint SA 3000. Although good yes, I believe what you are missing is the smoothness associated with the higher end products, you were most likely hearing the hard edgeyness detail.
zar OP
185 posts
 
Sid, it really does sound good and I am happy with the playback section. Until the Marantz laser went out I had never really used this one for playback. Pleasantly surprised to say the least. Thinking of keeping it for more than just recording duties that's for sure.
sid42
301 posts
 
Zar, I have the same CD recorder you have, and the recorder was designed for playback use on the right side as you are doing. Why should it hurt it? I also like the sound from the right tray. If money is tight, use it as you are.
dopogue
1,773 posts
 
My Tascam CD-RW700 is a terrific CD recorder but a mediocre player.
lplayer
28 posts
 
I have a Denon studio recorder and player (2 in 1) that I use to record albums to CD. It also functions as one of my CDP's. No problems there. WOnderful sounding IMO.
loomisjohnson
1,903 posts
 
i used a philips cdr 765 as a main cdp (both with and without a dac) for quite awhile and really liked it--read everything i threw at it + i could play two discs in succession. well built, nice sounding unit.
zar OP
185 posts
 
TP, just looking for opinions. $$ is tight right now as I head in to 3 months of no salary. I really am tempted to sell the SA-14 with the stipulation of what repairs are needed and a adjusted price. Have also thought about buying another player. It's been quite a hassle as the repair shop tries to figure out what's wrong. Onhwy61, good one! Mapman, good to hear I'm not alone. Maybe I'm not crazy.
mapman's avatar
mapman
21,825 posts
 
I have for a number of years. My Denon replaced a California Audio Labs icon Mkii that croaked nicely.

Most of my playback comes of the music server these days, but thats no fault of the player/recorder.
tpreaves's avatar
tpreaves
2,681 posts
 
Why would you even care?
onhwy61's avatar
onhwy61
5,134 posts
 
I'm not saying I ever tried it, but if I did do it I wouldn't admit to it let alone put it on the internet. If I were you I'd have this post removed before the Audiophile Special Squad (A-S-S) kicks in your door and takes away your special decoder ring.
Log in to respond
More to discover
80x80
McIntosh MCD-1100
80x80
Sonnet Digital Audio Pasithea
80x80
Ayon Audio CD-35 II Signature
AWARD WINNING 8 YEARS RUNNING