The Sony's are the best from reviews and personal experience. PSB good Sony better.
21 responses Add your response
I asked a similar question a few years ago and was convinced by the responses that instead of looking for headphones with active noise cancellation (ANC) that sounded better than my Bose over-ear I was looking to upgrade from that I’d be better off with the passive noise cancellation from a good set of IEMs. IEMs will be much smaller for your carry-on or to tote around town and Shure (for example) advertise 46dB reduction in outside noise levels.
The noise reduction is definitely different from ANC in that it is across the spectrum and all frequencies with good IEMs as opposed to ANC that often works best only with constant background noise (like airplane engines or the lawnmower) but works less for sudden sounds that aren’t constant which instead sound muffled/wrong but definitely get through.
I ended up with a pair from Campfire Audio and love them, but there are lots of IEMs that will blow away the best ANC headphones for sound quality at the same price.
I’m not a huge Sony fan, but I have to say at around the $300 price level I’d go with the Sony WH-1000XM4 for it’s all-around solid performance. That said, I just bought my wife a pair of Sennheiser PXC 550-ll for $200 for Christmas that seem pretty comparable but not quite as good noise cancelling as the Sony. I’ll report back on sound quality when I get to hear them. Won’t buy Bose. Hope this helps, and best of luck.
One last thought I’m not quite sure about, but the Senns offer a wired connection that allows for lossless quality, and if you can stick a DAC or DAC/Amp in there (like an Audioquest Dragonfly Red) so much the better. This would push me toward the PXC 550-ll for the potentially higher sound quality if it’s valid.
With respect to traveling, I have had several pairs of in ear IEMs and also active noise cancelling headphones including Sennheiser and Bose for long haul flights, working, listening to music and / or watching movies.
I loved a pair of JH Audio IEMs which were custom made and wonderfully comfortable. I get, however, a certain claustrophobia with even the best and most comfortable IEMs that I do not get with active noise cancelling headphones.
Both types would be good.
The ever popular Bose QC35 II (8/10 WIRED Recommends) remains a fantastic noise-canceling option, but Bose’s newest flagship headphones, the Noise Cancelling 700, take our top spot for business users. They have excellent noise reduction that quiets clacky keyboards or chatty roommates better than ever, plus slightly better sound quality and battery life than the QC35 II MCDVOICE
Sony WH4’s. Just bought (and returned) a pair. The noise cancellation is great, they are super comfortable if they fit properly (the were hitting my right ear funny so I took them back. This was more an issue with my ear and not the headphones).
They sound pretty good once eq’d from the phone app. They are waaay too bass heavy with the eq set at flat.
Phone calls sound great, the bluetooth has a wide range, the battery life is pretty good... for active noise cancelling, wireless, phone call, they are probably the best. The build qualityisgood and even though they are mostly plastic, they do not make any creaking noises. They are on sale now for $300.
My problem is being totally dependent on the internal-electronics within the headphones. They do sound better hardwired to a nice headphone amp / dac but only with dsp turned on. With no dsp turned on and the headphones plugged into a headphone amp, they sound like $5 headphones. Absolutely horrendous. Turn on the dsp though and they sound pretty dang good.
The ultimate problem for me though is how close they are in price to the Sundaras (open back planar) and the Shndaras should blow the Sonys away. And if I were going for noise cancellation I’d go passive noise cancellation and get a pair of planar in ear monitors ghag sojnd superior to the Sonys for have the price. Again though, comparing apples to oranges.
The sony wh4 is probably the best at what it does!
Late to the party..
BOSE and SONY came out top, and I spent quite a lot of time trying to justify paying the price of the BOSE ones (I went and tested both, in different environments), but in the end I couldn’t. I got the SONY WH1000XM3 headphones. Marco (from ATP) has a pretty good list of bluetooth cans to refer to.