Can a off the shelf DAC, if engineered/implemented good, sound as good as a custom DAC?


I heard 2 conflicting rules for DAC chips:

1) It's not so much about the DAC chip, but how well it is implemented

2) Custom DAC chips will beat off the shelf DAC (ie ESS) chips anyday 

 

So my question is... if for instance, the all in one DAC streamer Sim Audio Moon 891 which uses a ESS DAC chip... can it sound as good a Grimm Audio MU2, Lumin X2, or M3I which all have custom in house dacs? 

dman777

@mclinnguy    Excellent quote by Charles Hansen.

In addition to what other posters have stated - in my revealing system, the SQ from my DAC changes with the type of power cord installed.   What’s strange about that is my DAC is battery-operated.  It should be immune from AC input.  Perhaps, the battery runs part of the circuitry - but not all of it.  Or maybe, the effects are parasitic.   

So, if AC to a DAC affects the SQ, the next question is how clean is the AC power that’s feeding the system?   

- - -

Re: SQ.   Also, add the impact of the digital interconnect.   Let’s not forget tube-rolling for tube DAC’s.    Everything matters!

😂 😂 😂 😂 

Custom FPGA is a joke compared to what the best modern chips can do. And the chips achieved perfection years ago. 

  call Al at space tech labs. He’s a really cool older Japanese fella and he’ll beg you whatever you want. I can’t remember the website I think it’s space techlabs.com. If you google it it pops right out. I have a DAC that he built that’s beautiful and sounds amazing and a preamp he always answers his phone when something comes up he’s a real great dude.