I am very encouraged by this thread. Thanks for the question. I have lurked on these forums for decades, not having the resources to join in the conversation.
It seems to me the one thing changing the most over those years is the improvement of digital equipment and content.
I have several hundred NM vinyl albums I picked up in my youth that sound great. Against a million digital songs, however, how can that library ever be as "involving"? I get that OP's involving was referring to equipment, but another critical consideration, imo, is the source material (as some have stated).
A recent example came when listening to Fragile by Yes. When I compared the 2025 remaster on Spotify lossless to my OG vinyl, it was as if Jon Anderson was not even in the room on the vinyl. I'll never play that record again and it makes no sense for me to spend my grandchildren's money building (rebuilding) a vinyl library. So, I have chosen to fund the equipment supporting the ever improving digital channel. In the end, I find digital very involving on both the equipment and content levels. I also think it has no limit ahead. Look how far it has come.
To be fair, an easy choice where I don't have the investment in the analog.
Enjoy the music!

