Listening and evaluating equipment and systems.


I have found that listening to music is far more complex than simply hearing sound. A quick audition can reveal whether a system is bright, dull, thin, congested, or initially impressive. It tells us much less about whether it allows us to live with music… to relax into a performance, follow its structure, and keep discovering something in familiar recordings.

Critical listening can be useful, but it can also mislead. When we focus the mind’s ear on one sound… a drum strike, cymbal, vocal phrase, or bass note… much of the rest of the music recedes from awareness. If that sound is intermittent, we are only sampling brief fragments while other instruments are entering, fading, sustaining, and interacting. A speaker is never reproducing one isolated sound. Everything happening at once affects the whole presentation.

Music is a gestalt… rhythm, tone, dynamics, timing, space, harmony, and emotional intent occurring together. A system may impress by spotlighting details, yet prove less convincing over hours or days of actual listening. Another may seem less spectacular at first, but preserve the natural flow and wholeness of a performance more successfully.

The better test is to stop moving attention from one audiophile cue to another. Play complete albums over days or weeks and let the music direct your attention. A few minutes of analysis may identify a trait. Extended, undirected listening will tell you whether the system is truly right.

ghdprentice

Tonality-check

dynamics-check

No audible noise and distortion:  check

How will it pan out?  Time will tell  

 

 

I  like to sit back and relax and listen to my system. Now that I'm retired I have more time.But I buy so many freaking cds,that alot of the time ,I have never heard of the artist  or the music.Its great when you discover, something great ,but sometimes you say ,what the heck was that crap.

@ghdprentice 

What a well written and insightful post.  I congratulate you.  However, IMHO, you make being an audiophile and listening to music via ones high-end audio system sound like some kind of a real job or something Lol!!!  A strenuous task, a source of high stress, something that is long suffering, and even painful Lol!!!  High-end audio is supposed to bring peace to ones life, joy, relaxation, pleasure, and extreme enjoyment.  Isn’t it?  Happy listening.            

@ghdprentice 

Thought provoking and very well articulated.

Only been a serious 'hobbyist' for just over a year now. What I realised is from your post, is that there are 2 different 'states' of listening - one for enjoyment and one for analysing. 

I fall more into the first group. I don't listen for individual instruments etc. - more the sum of the parts, getting immersed into the music.  The goose flesh moments are actually the silence - between notes, the deliberate pauses in the music, the rythm - the gestalt you mentioned.  

How I listen depends on the state of my system. 
System state -

  • stable: I know what it’s capable of, you’re content with it, enjoy the music. 
  • evolving: I’ve made a change and am listening critically for how this change affects synergy, tonal characteristics, etc. does it work, does it all gel…the mind is switched into critical/analytical listening mode at this point where you begin to use music to evaluate your system. To get out of this state of mind can take me days and it’s time I spend away from the system. Need to perform a reset. This can take longer than a week.

Funny that I enjoy the stable state the most. But can’t help it and get into the analytical listening mode and start looking for flaws. It’s important to recognize that and just walk away. Unless upgrading is what you’ve set out to do.