@zlone I think you are right, ill probably go with a Siemens.
Electric Panel Surge protection
So, initially, I was thinking of getting a Puritan PSM156 which handles surge protection.
However, ever since, I had an issue with some surges at home (garage panel died as an example), I had spoken to my electrican (friend of the family) and he suggested to surge protect my whole panel/home.
I was suggested to get this model from my audio store, might be overkill? TPD TK-TTLP-1S240-FL , comes with a lifetime warranty.
My question first is, how many of you surge protect your whole panel and does this really then make it worry free for my audio equipment? and only need to get a power conditioner after that doesn't have surge protection?
Once I can get some feedback on this, then I can move onto looking at models to get after.
- ...
- 30 posts total
@jpwarren58 yes, I do get surges (tend to lose power about 2-3 times every winter) and pray I never get a lightning strike kind. |
I’ve installed a Siemens First Surge at the main panel (replacing an Eaton before that), but also use additional point of use surge protection in the house for computers, printer and TV system as well as certain appliances like the microwave oven. My main hi-fi system is fed by a 10kVa Iso Transformer that has a surge board inside the NEMA case, which obviates the need for any point of use surge protection for the individual components. My vintage Quad Loudspeakers are plugged into a ZeroSurge--since they need to be powered up for at least 24 hours before playing (not true for later Quad stats as far as I know). I also have a whole house back up generator 26kVA that has its own service panel. Only the appliances wired to that secondary panel are "backed up" by the generator and that panel has a surge protector on it when normally operating from the grid. If it throws over to the generator for power due to electrical service going down, the generator has surge protection integrated into its electronics. I used this wiring scheme in part to avoid having the automatic transfer switch (ATS) in the same circuit as the main hi-fi. I am not supporting the big hi-fi system with generator power- if we lose grid power, I’m not interested in running the hi-fi from the backup generator. FWIW, to answer your question whether whole house surge protection obviates the need for point of use type, the folks at ZeroSurge claim that a lot of surges are internal to your household circuitry and according to them, a whole house surge unit is not a complete solution. I’ve covered my bets by using both and on the big hi-fi, I hear no negative effects from the Iso Transformer with built-in surge board. |
This is backed up by the wording of the National Electric Code, as well as the fine print in the publication of most reputable whole house surge protectors. It gets lost in translation when electricians are selling them on their websites. They'll say "protects your whole house!" but not give you the details, making you think your PC and TV are good when they aren't. Important to note that no surge protector guarantees survival from a catastrophic surge strike, but 99% of damaging surges are the one’s you wouldn’t know hit anyway. In my area we get 2 power events a month, sometimes storm, sometimes unfortunate interaction of a power pole and a vehicle, sometimes just power company failures. I don’t know when they will happen, I can’t proactively disconnect my system so I chose to use multiple layers of surge protection all the time. |
BTW, the patents on series mode protection expired a while ago and Furman among others now incorporates them into their designs. Looking at the only 3rd party tests I know of, from Wired, the latest Furman and Tripp Lite models outperform Brickwall and ZeroSurge and also add nice additional features. |
- 30 posts total

