I once picked out a DVD from the library that was unbelievably filthy. It had scratches, divots, a corn syrupy like goo and ground chocolate in it. This is the polycarbonate disc that was the most challenging I ever in encountered. I soaked in the kitchen sink with warm water and Dawn for about 5 minutes before wiping it with a cloth. I then probably had to do 3 separate spray and wipe cycles with isopropyl but I got it to play in the cheap Sony Blu Ray that I was using at the time.
Perhaps a higher end player would have been less forgiving? At any rate if that plays, anything will.

