Listening and evaluating equipment and systems.


I have found that listening to music is far more complex than simply hearing sound. A quick audition can reveal whether a system is bright, dull, thin, congested, or initially impressive. It tells us much less about whether it allows us to live with music… to relax into a performance, follow its structure, and keep discovering something in familiar recordings.

Critical listening can be useful, but it can also mislead. When we focus the mind’s ear on one sound… a drum strike, cymbal, vocal phrase, or bass note… much of the rest of the music recedes from awareness. If that sound is intermittent, we are only sampling brief fragments while other instruments are entering, fading, sustaining, and interacting. A speaker is never reproducing one isolated sound. Everything happening at once affects the whole presentation.

Music is a gestalt… rhythm, tone, dynamics, timing, space, harmony, and emotional intent occurring together. A system may impress by spotlighting details, yet prove less convincing over hours or days of actual listening. Another may seem less spectacular at first, but preserve the natural flow and wholeness of a performance more successfully.

The better test is to stop moving attention from one audiophile cue to another. Play complete albums over days or weeks and let the music direct your attention. A few minutes of analysis may identify a trait. Extended, undirected listening will tell you whether the system is truly right.

ghdprentice

How I listen depends on the state of my system. 
System state -

  • stable: I know what it’s capable of, you’re content with it, enjoy the music. 
  • evolving: I’ve made a change and am listening critically for how this change affects synergy, tonal characteristics, etc. does it work, does it all gel…the mind is switched into critical/analytical listening mode at this point where you begin to use music to evaluate your system. To get out of this state of mind can take me days and it’s time I spend away from the system. Need to perform a reset. This can take longer than a week.

Funny that I enjoy the stable state the most. But can’t help it and get into the analytical listening mode and start looking for flaws. It’s important to recognize that and just walk away. Unless upgrading is what you’ve set out to do. 

I don’t think listening to music is complex at all. Normally, you can start listening to a system and within a few seconds you can tell if you are a fan or just want to leave. Maybe it’s because of all the audio shows for the past 30 years I’ve attended. I have walked into a room, sat down and listened for 10 seconds then got up and left. But there are only a couple of rooms where things sound great, you stay longer, then you go grab your audio friends and bring them back to the room and you are sitting there for 30 mins just gathering it all in. Same goes for buddies systems, you either like them or not, but during a session, you try to find reasons why others find this system engaging when you don’t. 

Similar to others above, I listen critically after I have made a change in my system. And only for the time required to hear, or not hear, the results from the change. Otherwise, I listen purely for the joy that music gives me. I just tune everything rlse out and let it carry me away. 

Mr. ghdprentice

 

Thank you for your very accurate and well articulated analysis.  It was very helpful and could prevent many from spur of the moment purchases and act as a guide to system building.

Thanks

There are so many variables when listening or evaluating music via equipment.  I can usually evaluate the sound very quickly if I like the sound I am hearing or not within a few minutes.  The problem is I many not know what is contributing to my opinion,  Is it the room, electronics or speakers.  My other casual test is if I want to turn the music up or down.  Up is an encouraging.  Many times the speakers will be my first point of contention or approval.  We all have tonal characteristics that meet our criteria.  In the end you just need to sit back and relax and turn the critical mind off and enjoy the music.