Break In Question?


I have been under the assumption that in order for a component to break in there must be a signal pass through from one piece of equipment to another. That is, running a Dac/Preamp into an amp, the amp must be turned on for the Dac/Preamp to break in.

But is this really true? Does the amp really need to be turned on?

ozzy

ozzy

Doug, 

My impression is similar. It is as if you are hiding a seed of conspiracy theory and attempting to lure people to buy your book it to find out what it is. It is not alluring at all.

@douglas_schroeder - No, I don't need to read the book you are hawking (they're allowing free ads on Agon these days via this back-door route?). Nothing you have to say will explain to me about the headphones on the chair, either. 

@ghdprentice + 1 - I guess those people who deny the fact of break-in think that all those manufacturers' figures are nothing but lies and only the gullible would believe them. 

@ghdprentice  Thx for posting links to your book.  Wow!    It’s like a doctoral dissertation.    Congratulations on such a massive and arduous undertaking!  I’ve read only one chapter so far.  I look forward to reading more.

- - - 

@larsman I had some Grado RS2e, liked them, listened to them a bunch, so they were broken in. Then got some Dan Clark Ether 2 listened to them a bunch. Then went back to the broken-in Grado, and they sounded horrible to me. 

Clear case of psychoacoustics and habituation. Very real.

For mechanical items there *may* be some break-in (speakers, carts, cans). But electronics, fat chance. Easy test. Get two identical electronic components, break one in, leave the other untouched. Then do blind A-B comparison and see whether you can reliably distinguish the two. Say 8 out of 10 or whatever number of tries you want. Simple chi-square test with 50/50 being the null hypothesis (no discernible difference). Good luck!

Also, long-term auditory memory is infamously poor. I think Amir cited some papers on that. Would have to dig them out. Short-term quick switches are much more likely to pick out differences.