Have you ever thought it would be cool to have a stereo reviewer come to your house?


While I was listening to my system today, I started thinking it would be really fun to invite one or more stereo system reviewers from magazines or blogs over for a blind listening session. I wouldn’t let them see the room or the equipment at all. They could play whatever music they like, form their impressions, rate the system, and even guess how much was spent on it. After that, I’d reveal everything and see how close they came. I’ve always been curious how my setup stacks up against the kinds of systems these reviewers hear all the time.

baclagg

@audioman58

That’s why they would be blindfolded without seeing the room or equipment. I want to see if they can really hear the difference and how much that difference is decided by price and brand names.

@audioman58 

Yep, some of the TAS reviewer's have expensive rigs that they probably got for free or at least for cost and then took that cost and took it off their taxes.

@sksos1 

Who’s Johnathon Valin?

@baclagg 

I’ve never thought about having a reviewer come to my home, but now that I’m thinking about it now, I’d have to say no.I think I would be afraid he’d nitpick everything to death.  Your speakers are to tall,  your power cord should be shorter. Your amplifier is underpowered.  Oh, I don’t like that brand.

Who’s Johnathon Valin?

Jonathan Valin is a reviewer for The Absolute Sound.

I have reviewed for 20 years for Dagogo.com and over that time have built hundreds of systems with most genres of components and speakers. While I cannot visit everyone's home who wishes, I can tell everyone plainly what my assessment is of their system building methods, which influences the sound quality. 

I have written a book The Audiophile Laws which details the factors influencing  system building, reveals the mistakes that many make, and corrects how to advance an audio system. 

If I may, baclagg, offer a suggestion based on the images and description of your system. After all, you half-invited me to come over. So, in lieu of a visit, I offered what I can in assessment of your system. (I have a pretty good idea of what your system's basic characteristics would sound like, but no one can tell the fine characteristics without hearing it, and certainly it would be a mess to attempt a discussion of such fine attributes sans listening session). 

You are using an ad hoc mix of cables, which is a mistake in system building. Anyone who uses a mix of cables has no idea what they are doing; it's nothing more than guessing at it. The only proper way to advance an audio system through cables is to compare entire sets. I suggest no less than three sets of power cords, interconnects, and speaker cables, and if available, digital cable, etc.

This is quite a bit more effort and potentially much more costly, but it is the means to select cables that will elevate the system on the order of changing a component. Most audiophiles do not wish to invest that much time and money. If you were to compare sets of cables, you would elevate your system's sound dramatically. 

I explain in my book how I arrived at that principle and many others through actual system building, not the received wisdom of the industry and community. In practice, many of my Audiophile Laws encourage the audiophile to do the opposite of most reviewers.