blue_strat-
Guessing your previous tubed ARC linestage had phonostage, so you were hearing a tubed presentation?
With that in mind, you won't be hearing the "tube magic" with any SS unit. Maybe the "finest/SOTA" approach this, but that's not you're looking for.
macg19 comments are telling:
"I sold my PH-10 & PSU-10 after buying a $650 Softone Model 4 on a whim to pair with my MSL Platinum. It wasn’t a close contest,
Running NOS Mullard’s but also got great results with RCA triple micas.
its not pretty but the mute button is great and its as quiet as the GoldNote."
Waiting for someone tube curious:
Softone Model4 Phono Stage (120 Volt) For Sale - US Audio Mart
As others suggested synergy won't get any better than ARC phono.
New tubed @$5K - I use this
PrimaLuna EVO 100 Phonostage - The Absolute Sound
If you're MIC averse not for you. Otherwise on par with any real tube phono units out there-maybe "better" in some areas?
Used-
ModWright PH 9.0X Tube Phono Stage - The Music Room