I have several ( read too many!) NOS testing small signal tubes; 12AX7, 5751, & 12AT7. I’d rank them as follows:
1. Telefunken, smooth and ribbed plates. I can’t tell much difference in the two. Clean, clear, detailed and neutral throughout frequency range, top to bottom. The reference standard. Great for hours of non fatiguing listening.
2. Amperex Bugle Boy. Similar to the Telefunkens but with sparkle and shimmer on top end. Big, expansive sound stage. Nice wow factor.
3. Raytheon black plates. Warmer, “darker” with great mid and lower bass. Also big soundstage. My favorite for jazz and acoustic folk.
RCA black plates and GE 5 star next in line, then Sylvania black plates.Mullard and Brimar veiled and “softer” without any wow factor in my system.
Teles top technically.

