Streaming Is To Audio What Red Plastic Cups Are To Wine


Unpacking and going through my vinyl collection, it occurs to me that vinyl is it, whereas streaming is Audio’s red plastic cup.

The best wines taste low-shelf in the red plastic cup. Yes, the red plastic cup is cheap and convenient, just like streaming. Wine should feel the same regardless of the vessel - it’s the same wine - but it does not. So should music - but it does not. Streamed music may sound (nearly) as good as vinyl, but it feels... disposable. Vinyl does not. Vinyl is the thing. Vinyl is it! Just my opinion, of course.

devinplombier

I listen to both vinyl and streaming. My vinyl system is higher end than my streaming system: VPI Prime Signature 21 (the best of belt VPI) with a Fatboy arm; and Shyla cartridge; Pass Labs XP-25 phono preamp;. All of that vinyl grear is about $35k. For streaming I own a Moon 280D, a decent streamer but not equivalent to my vinyl gear at all. It's well reviewed, but today a $4k streamer would sound better. 

I write in the mornings and listen to music while I write, almost always LPs, jazz and classical. MY afternoon listening usually moves to streaming. That's where I get to hear new music for free. I test out albums to see if I want to buy them. When I stream at 192 Khz, it comes close to albums. Much closer on high, high-end streamers. And I don't care that much about quality. Well, I usally stop listening if the quality is CD 44.1 Khz. It's flat and jangly. But 48 or 96 Khz or above, I'm happy with. 

I have all 3 media: vinyl, CD, and streaming. Last week my wife asked to listen to  Sting album she received for Christmas. I admit, we haven't listened to vinyl in awhile - out of convenience - and was shocked at how good the vinyl sounded, smoother, more 'organic'. For reference my vinyl rig consists of a VPI Prime Scout w/ JMW Mrmorial 10.5 3D printed epoxy armtube and a Hana SH High Output MC running into a Marantz Model 40 Streaming Integrated Amp and driving Monitor Audio Silver 300 7G. I also have an office streaming-only system with JM Lab/Focal 'Chorus' standmounts, and a dedicated Dolby Atmos 5.2.2 home theater with a 4K projector and 110" screen that also streams, and a 55" Main Bedroom TV with a Sonos Arc (more Atmos!) and subwoofer. I have both Blue Note and Wiim Ultra streamers and a couple outboard DACs, and Several of the Nelson Pass designed Adcom MOSFET amps and a modified APT One preamp that continues to impress me after over 40 years ownership, and a pair of LS-50s and a pair of Maggie LRS for fun. None of my gear is eye-wateringly priced high-end, or impossible to service esoterica, but it is good enough for me to assess source and component quality. 

Streaming audio can sound great, but too often it has passed through too many CODECS and disparate reconstruction filters that don't always exactly put the bits back together the same way, and those accumulated small errors are audible. In fact, the only meaningful and repeatable SQ differences I've heard in DACs are from different reconstruction filters. Vinyl suffers none of that, and is to my ear, what people enjoy most about the medium.

When I first started streaming, I had the same opinion as the OP. Vinyl is king. My opinion is that a streamer puts out numbers. The real magic happens in the DAC. I’m set to get a MIMIC SW1X  Balanced Special II tube Dac in about a month. The dealer has agreed to break it in for me, before I audition it. I currently have a Kora Hermes II and it bests my albums hands down. I couldn’t believe it, but I’ve been converted. Still love vinyl, but Qobuz sounds great!

Post removed 

I love music .....even since a kid listening on my little pocket radio.But yes vinyl is great on a good system...I mean if l listened to 45s o. My mother's old welcome record player....which was little did I know a pretty good record player.My stepfather console stereo was nice...I had one of those...combos that came out in the late,60s...turn table,cd player,tuner...I like cassettes on my Panasonic cassettes player...Then got a good tt Technics sl 1350,Bose 901s,and Sony Str 7065 received...a nice Sony double cassettes deck..up graded through the years .A nice Onkyo cd player that was $500 bucks....always,brush cleaned my lps before playing  and took care of them....hey cheap is cheap....yeah  but does a glass make a cheap wine taste better....I think cheap is cheap...Boones Farm in a Crystal glass is still cheap.Maybe its me.....lol....Yes a nice lp on my system sounds great...but my cds sound great too....which sounds,better that depends,on how many plastic cups of wine I have....