What, only one or the other? Not a few of each at once? That’s way too little chaos for me to enjoy a hobby with...
If you have one egregiously below level of the other, then do that one. Otherwise, get which you fancy more; it doesn’t really matter. New cartridges are probably a better dopamine hit (on average) but phono stages can stick around for multiple carts, don’t need alignment, and don’t wear out (so much).

