High Value Phono Stages


The current phono stage is an Esoteric E-03, which I am quite content with. I have an Origin Live Agile w Transfiguration Proteus on one input and an OG Kiseki Blackheart on an Audiomods 12" Series 6 on the other. 

I have a third tonearm, an Audiomods 10.5" Series 6 in the system with a Benz Micro Glider on it going into the onboard phono stage of the Trinov. Which is OK, but not excellent. I have a 4th tonearm that may come into play some day. 

So what do you like in good quality phono stages that may not be TOTL pieces. I know the Darlington is a popular answer. Graham Slee often is. Some folks like the SOTA Pyxi. 

Thoughts on output devices, topology and so forth are certainly welcome. Not a SUT user so that is not on the table. I have to admit that small format stages are interesting, like the Ray Samuels Nighthawk. 

 

Any thoughts?

neonknight

Wspohn, I and the internet remember the Classe DR3 as a 25W Class A amplifier that was indeed excellent sounding, but how are you getting 500W out of it, even in bridged mode? As I recall it ran quite hot even producing 25W owing to Class A operating.

I had, briefly, a Ray Samuels Emmeline 2 box phono stage. I say 'briefly' as that was how I learned that Positive Feedback reviews did not always translate into real life for me.

Now I'm quite happy with my NuVista Vinyl, but I know that you, OP, were less impressed. So, horses for courses. Maybe a Ray Samuels will work for you!

Both the Hagerman and Graham Slee are from a Brand that also produces DIY designs. 

I see DIY is not broached upon in replies made. 

DIY offers options, that in some designs will most likely show the design is easily surpassing some of the Branded Models suggested

A particularvTom Evans Phon' Model, has been publicly scrutinised as a Model marketed at £25K. The same model is proven to be doable as a parts only BOM, using earlier known pricing, for close to £1K.

I would suggest approx' £1.5K if produced as a commission build.

My experiences are showing BOM's of £500 - £1K for a Phon' design to be DIY built are hit and miss, with a few encountered being able to impress.

Same Phon' designs are very easily surpassed in End Sound performance when the BOM for the design are approaching £2K and over. 

My experiences had, of a small cross section of the commercially available Branded Phon's offered to market. Where prices come in at under £5K retail, have some very wanting models in the mix, with a few only that contend with a more expensive commercially available model. 

In a different context, I have experienced DIY designs at close  to £2.5K as the BOM, that have been toe to toe as a competitor to commercially produced £10K + models. 

 

Pindac, I fully agree that DIY designs can exceed commercially available designs, for fewer bucks.  What I have done historically is to buy very good commercial designs and then experiment using my own painfully developed and always developing expertise to make them better.  Mostly because building from scratch is quite tedious, and I don’t have the time for it.  I spent a few decades studying the subject before engaging in such ventures, and I still to this day am loathe to mess around with the RIAA filter. So my question is, where do you expect the average guy among us to find the skill to "DIY" or where to find the private individual who has the expertise to do it for you?  (You apparently know such individuals in the UK, but here in the US they are rare birds and are slowly dying off as well.) And such persons do not usually want to work for free and never work to a time clock.  Before I got into actual DIM (Do IT Myself), I once lost use of an MFA Luminescence preamp for nearly a year while I waited for a private hobbyist to upgrade it. By the time I got it back, I had totally forgotten how it sounded beforehand and so could not say really whether it was improved.