Bass Traps


Anyone familiar with these 2 types of bass traps?

Synergistic Research Black Box and PSI AUDIO AVAA C214

I'm in the process of implementing room treatment and have decided on 32x32x6 hollow felt box clouds stuffed with 6" Rockwool Safe and Sound acoustic insulation.  This will offer an NRC value of 1.25. These panels are manufactured with WAF in mind,  not that I actually need my wife's approval lol

But as far as controlling the bass, given the aesthetics of my room I'm limited in what I can and want to do. So I'm wondering how effective these two types of bass traps actually perform. Those huge passive black foam blocks and wedges won't work with the aesthetics of my room.  Let's not pretend they are anything but conspicuous and visually disruptive.  

Again I'm looking for feedback on the Synergistic Research Black Box and PSI AUDIO AVAA C214

Thanks!

fire_water

Seeing an acoustician and/or learning REW are wise choices.  Bass problems and treatment should be dealt with objectively.  The graphs in the review are evidence of effectiveness.

I remain an advocate for the AVAA traps but only if you have some assurance that they are the right choice and that there are not less expensive options. 

  

I have a friend who is running PSI Audio AVAA C20s in all four corners of this listening room.  This is a different unit than you asked about but I will say that this room running the active traps is the best sounding bass I've ever heard.  I think this is worth pursuing.  Good luck and cheers. 

Just one question why Rockwall and not Owens Corning 703 rigid panel? 

OC 703 is not very effective in a 6" thick application. It won't reach very low. 6" Rockwool will make a better bass trap.

I almost pulled the trigger on the PSI Audio product but felt it would not contribute much beyond what a distributed bass array system would. The graphs at the end of my Virtual System photos show the benefit of a DBA, which also provides other enhancements beyond decreasing bass modes, such as bass extension and better imaging. 

I am curious as to whether Kal thinks the AVAA could still provide additional benefit.

 

@kr4 can I place the PSI AUDIO AVAA C214 directly behind the couch of my sitting area or on your experience is it better to keep it upfront.  I can probably only do 1 unit now and a 2nd one later