For me, sound quality is necessary condition but not a sufficient one. Conversely, as the sound quality gets better, I find that I enjoy a wider range of music.
I don’t usually play the same albums over and over again. Yet sometimes, I'll have a period of listening to a series of albums by one particular artist, which may necessitate switching to streaming.
New albums tend to get played two or three times, then set aside to come back to later.
I have an on going project to clean and listen to all my records in alphabetical order. So far, I’ve only given up on one I didn’t like and one that is in bad condition. The latter I’ve earmarked to be replaced when I find another copy.