Recommend The Best No Frills Preamp up to $5K.

It's not under $5k unless you can find one used, but the Linear Tube Audio MicroZOTL preamp is quite good.  Mine is a level 2.  The newest version is level 3.

It replaced a more lush sounding conrad-johnson preamp. I thought I might miss the "warmth", but I don't.  I prefer the LTA. 

+1 for Don Sachs pre.  I’ve had one for a few years that unexpectedly outperformed and replaced an AR-6se.  It really is that good. 

Assuming you already have a phonostage, and are looking for a dynamic sounding, “no frills” linestage, you might consider the Hattor Autoformer Reference Preamplifier for $2910 (RCA only) or $4774 (rca and XLR). (link)

A passive preamplifier but with the impedance benefits of autoformers, so no loss of tone or dynamics as is common with resistor based passives. Excellent clarity, tone, and dynamics for the price.  Nice display, multiple inputs/outputs, dual mono (so balance control), and all functions accessible through the metal remote control.

Hattor’s The Big Passive/Active Ultimate Preamplifier with three user adjustable gain options is another great sounding linestage for the price.

There are tons of preamps, so you are probably overwhelmed with recommendations.

My suggestion is to audition the Bryston BP-19. It is the acclaimed analog circuitry from the BR-20, but minus all the digital sections. There are online dealers that have return policies if you do not have a Bryston dealer in your area. 

Happy Listening!