What phono preamp are you using?

I went from a Parasound JC3 Jr., to Herron VTPH-2A, to PS Audio Stellar. With a 1200G and Ortofon Quintet Black.  Surprisingly to me, the Herron and PS Audio were basically a toss-up.  The Stellar is dead quite and sounds great.

"Fosgate Signature V2 with Audio Technica Art-9"

Same setup as melm. Both(Foz out of production) excellent pieces. Presently have a Kiseki Blue thru the Foz.

Soundsmith is a great choice. Get the most you can afford. You will have the ability to send it back when it needs a tune up. Used a $399 entry level  Soundsmith Otello. It's "the best" in case of emergency, break glass-back up cart I've heard so far.

Yaqin MS12B, Built in Phono in Plinius M16, MAGI Phonomenal, and Allnic H1202.

TW ACUSTIC RPS 100 one of the best made in my opinion. 

PS Audio Stellar with a wide variety of cartridges. Currently Gold Note Donatello Black.