The Best Sounding Systems can Play Loudly with Low Distortion


Pretty much what the title states. What say you? 

helomech

"Best for whom?" is always my question.  I actually think playing speakers loudly, when that’s NOT how you listen to music is a terrible idea.

That’s like needing a family van and racing it across the Mexican desert.  

Test/listen to speakers like you live. 

Leave the PA testing to live music performances. 
 

I see now I should’ve specified systems that come remotely close to bridging the gap between live, unamplified dynamic range, and those systems that merely playback recordings such that they sound like a miniaturized ensemble, with a clearly obvious smearing or veiling of transients and decay. In my experience, the systems that can sound great at very high SPLs also perform best at low SPLs. And it’s not so much a matter of speaker efficiency, rather, it’s a matter of total system distortion and headroom. The lowest distortion drivers remain the lowest distortion drivers whether played loud or softly, especially played softly. And if you know much about component contribution, you know the speaker’s driver quality is paramount, similar to room acoustics in that regard. 

 

To each their own.  I have two systems in my house.  One requires some oomph before the speakers open up and really perform their best.  I’ve run those speakers with three different amps of varying power.  I get the same result, meaning the speakers need a bit of power above what I consider quiet listening, before they really become dynamic.   The other speakers, which are in my listening room, sound dynamic at low volumes and keep it up to the point the volume is too loud for me.   Interestingly, the speakers in my listening room are supposedly not as sensitive (87db) as the speakers in the other room (96db).   It’s a mystery. 

One thing I have learned in my (relatively) short “audiophile” journey is that there is no such thing as too much headroom and I still hate tootsie pops & rolls.

85 dB is egregiously loud. OSHA wouldn't allow you to stay in an environment that loud for any length of time without ear protection. The reason your ears are ringing after a night of loud music is because your brain is trying to compensate for the permanent hearing loss you endured.

Interestingly, as the level of volume that occurs in a particular environment increases the human ear naturally and instantly becomes less sensitive to lower-level sounds and nuances, such as a fellow employee trying to talk to a coworker over the din of machinery in the background. Same thing happens in your listening room as you're try to discern the drummer's lightest brush strokes over the din of the horns in the band.

Low order harmonic distortion of the second and third variety in audio gear are naturally occurring in that humans are familiar with them in all manner of speaking whether it be acoustic music or the sounds of nature outdoors and are completely consonant with what the human ear is accustomed too. Higher order distortions 5th, 7th and 9th at least in electronics generally occur at much reduced levels and are reduced further in level with the negative feedback that gives an amplification device their gain. Intermodulation distortion on the other hand is insidious and quite audible from active electronic devices like preamps and amps and passive mechanical ones like phono cartridges and speakers. Pulse code modulation in DACs also produces significant amounts of intermodulation distortion as well as quantization noise keeping distortion levels no lower that .22%.

Dynamic driver distortion increases exponentially with increases in cone excursion. Electrostatics are limited in the amount of absolute level they can produce due to their very limited excursion capabilities. Among the ways to ameliorate the distortion issues with dynamic drivers is to limit cone excursion by horn loading them which again "exponentially" increases their efficiency and solves the problem of excessive cone excursion and reduces distortion as long as the speaker system isn't overdriven. You can also design direct radiators or baffle mounted drivers with underslung voice coils wherein the voice coil throughout it's range of excursion never leaves the magnetic gap as it moves back and forth. This requires fewer winds of wire on the former and enormous magnet structures to compensate for the "exponential" loss in efficiency and also reduces distortion as long as the speaker system isn't overdriven.

There is virtually no dynamic range to speak of at the typical rock concert in an auditorium, bar or club venue. It's just loud. If you go to a concert of unamplified classical music at the BSO, at times the SPLs might briefly reach a 100 dB in some parts of some compositions but most of the time you have to be absolutely quiet, shut up and sit still to hear everything that's going on, on stage. Classical chamber music was specifically commissioned by the elite to be played in specially designed ornate and reverberant rooms where a small group of listeners sat around a four or five piece ensemble while they played. Just a couple relative examples.

I have to agree with @ghdprentice a system that can play dynamics and full rich articulate bass at low volumes probably is just as important. 

Once you start getting up in the higher db's the room starts getting more involved so what can be a clean sounding low distortion system may sound "different" at those levels