Should AI generated posts be banned or otherwise regulated?


I just wonder. 

At least, when I start a new thread, I am expecting other people's opinions.  I can get my own AI response so I am not sure why others would repeat what I can do myself. 

If someone were to have access to some better AI than I have access to, I guess that would be useful info I could not otherwise get.  But in general, I wonder why posters think responding with AI content is useful to someone who can get that directly themselves. 

jji666

I appreciate the formatting of AI quotes in that they are instantly recognizable so that i just scroll. They are completely useless to me. 

I would certainly prefer to not see AI answers to questions about stereo. This site has been very helpful to me when people talk about their direct experience. I can ask AI questions, too, if needed. But it can't tell me how it feels to have that speaker in that room under those conditions. I'm here to find out how real people do things, and hear things, even if it is not exactly conventional "best practice." I just skip over the AI generated answers, and can continue to do that - it's not that big a deal. 

 

But if I had a vote, I'd vote to keep it centered on our own direct experiences.

 

David

No but seriously, One thing I like about Agon is it’s people talking to people.  There isn’t much of the slop that’s on Facebook. Here if I have a question people (intelligent or not) will answer me and I truly appreciate that.

AI is like everything else, its acceptability depends on how it’s used.

For instance, in this thread @hilde45 demonstrated an intelligent use of AI by showing us AI’s opinion of AI’s value to an audio-centric forum.

On the other hand, you have those people who literally cut-and-paste 3000 words of garbage in posts so interminable just scrolling through them puts you at risk of carpal tunnel syndrome.

Maybe those people also unzip in public and relieve themselves on parked cars whenever the mood strikes them. it’s offensive and discourteous to others, but so what? It’s quick and convenient! Same like pasting AI!

I think the answer is not in more rules and bans and enforcement, it is in members setting up etiquette, organically, and gently nudging folks in the right direction.