Pondering REL and Dynaudio subwoofers.


I recently got a rel classic 99 subwoofer, which sounds excellent and matches perfectly with my dynaudio heritage specials.  A thing is it has a well documented issue of a hum when my class D  Orchard Audio Starkrimson Ultra is powered off (also use Freya+ F).  I'm trying various methods to resolve that,.  Another option is to return that sub and get a dynaudio sub. 6.  I'm finding many features of the sub 6 being very intriguing.  DSP and matching base mgt with my Heritage specials.  I don't have a typical listening room, So my acoustics are not the best.

I'd be curious to hear any opinions on either the classic 99 or Sub 6.

 

grantgg

Sounds like a ground loop issue that won't be resolved with a different sub. Which devices have 2 prong and 3 prong? They might not agree with each other.

Try the Earthquake GLI-200 or ISO-200. If it makes the ground loop worse, run a ground line on your devices to the amp, or any other combination that might work.

I have Dynaudio speakers and REL subs.  no issues, but different amps.  How do you have them hooked up?  I had issues with hum some years back with different amps, and it was a matter of floating the yellow wire or grounding the yellow wire to a chassis of an amp... can't exactly remember!

it is a ground loop problem of sorts known to happen with class D amps. Rel support has confirmed that.  

Was interested if anyone has compared the dynaudio sub 6 to the REL.

You're considering two very different animals. 

If I'm understanding Dynaudio Sub6 spec "(Hz @ 85dB +/- 3dB): 16" as well as the manuals suggestion of placing the unit at the listening position to excite your rooms unique standing wave bass modes to position the Sub in, ie: the subwoofer crawl, the Sub6 is a true -3dB@16Hz subwoofer. Aside from this more detailed room integration the Sub6 appears to offer an application for far greater seamless speaker integration. In my experience with a big REL you ain't heard nothin' yet.

All REL products are merely Sub-Bass Systems (woofers) with a dramatic -6dB roll off that simply does not play loud enough to excite a rooms standing bass waves. This allows them to be placed most anywhere in the room. If your not concerned with hearing the delicate (not boomy) extra low frequency presentation found on most recordings and do not want to be bothered with locating your rooms standing wave modes then the Classic should do just fine, minus the Sub6's full presentation. 

Your amplifier manufacturer is the ultimate authority on grounding resolution not REL.

Your Freya has three sets of outputs. If the Sub6 position is a long distance away from the Freya you have the option to use inexpensive custom length XLR or single ended cables from Blue Jeans or Monoprice Cables. 

All the best with your search.

@grantgg 

d issue of a hum when my class D  Orchard Audio Starkrimson Ultra is powered off (also use Freya+ F)

it is a ground loop problem of sorts known to happen with class D amp

This sounds like a two part question.

1. If all your devices are 3-prong then the solution is to use a ground loop isolator, coupled with manually grounding the devices together, mentioned above. If the amp is off and there's a hum, then it seems to me the problem is another device that is powered on. The classic 99 or Sub 6 both use class D amplifiers and are 3-prong. The subs can also be the source of the problem.

 

If you're mixing a 2-prong devices to a 3-prong amplifier, it can cause a ground loop hum because the difference in grounding methods creates a path for noise. The 3-prong amp is grounded to the wall, while the 2-prong device is not, creating a potential difference. With this issue, you still need a ground loop isolator. A different subwoofer does not resolve the problem. Also, subwoofers often use class D amplifiers with a switch mode power supply and the switching frequency contributes to the hum or high pitch whine.

 

2. As to how the subs compare, per a REL video I've seen, the classic 99 is designed to give a slower, smooth bass that is a good match for vintage speakers or if you like that sound signature. Just looking at the Sub 6, it's designed for more punch and speed given the sealed, dual opposed drivers.