I should add that I did upgrade my center in the past year. The original one was rather smaller, 2 way which couldn't go very deep. Went from dual 5" woofers to dual 6.5" and a low cut off of around 100 Hz to 60 Hz, and passive to active.
The difference in the sense of fullness and weight was noticeable. After the upgrade though I can't tell if the center is on or off except sitting off-axis, so for this reason I think if the OP is hearing a big difference, his center may not be fully set up yet.

