Are exotic speaker cabinet materials overrated?


Seems a lot of speaker companies are coming out with new non resonant cabinet materials all the time. Wilson especially seems to be inventing a new M X V material every year. Other top speaker companies seem to be staying with MDF even when their speakers match the above mentioned speaker company prices. Do these exotic materials really contribute to a better sound or do they add an unnatural quality to the sound. 

 

hiendmmoe

The surface area of a 1ft3 cabinet is about 20X the surface area of an 8" woofer. Consequently the cabinet only has to move 5% as much as the woofer before it contributes as much 'noise' to the signal as the speaker itself, all of it a distortion of the original, and .5% as much motion of the box relative to the woofer generates unwanted sound, a very audible 10dB below the reference output of the woofer. So, either you live with it, or mitigate it with some combination of bracing, mass, constrained layer damping (KEF), cabinet geometry (Estolon) or materials (Wilson). or use it as a tuning device (Harbeth). Properly done, all can be effective in achieving the designers goals. All are preferable to ignoring the issue. A couple simple braces. A simple diagonal panel to break up both acoustical and panel resonant modes can be a very cost effective solution, adding a viscoelastic layer adds mass and dampens panel resonances, at some cost penalty. From there the sky is the limit, aerospace grade machined aluminum, molded mineral filled resin, concrete, you name it, its been tried. There's no magic bullet, one Holy grail of speaker cabinet building, just solid engineering, testing, and listening.

 

I'd be willing to bet that most of these "high-end" speakers are not made from solid exotic wood but veneers over HDF. Baltic Birch is good for screw retention but doesn't have as strong dimensional stability. I don't know of that many manufacturers that screw their cabinets together so there's that. HDF also has better uniformity and is much easier to work with on a production level. If you add some exotic veneers, it can look much better than Baltic Birch as well. I once had a custom set of DW drums that had an exotic veneer over maple. Maple was great but the veneer of Mapa Burl put it over the top. Does it look good? Sound good? And is inert? That's really all that matters. 

No they are not over-rated.  The stiffer and more inert the cabinet the more energy is converted into sound which is the point after all.

Best bookshelf speaker in the world has Granite Cabinets. No not overrated and @kofibaffour is clueless....