New Cartridge or New Stylus


Dear all,

I’m running a Sumiko Oyster with the original stylus on a Project turntable.  Curious what you think would have the greatest impact for improved dynamics and sound clarity for ~$150:

LP Gear ViVid Line Upgrade stylus for Sumiko Oyster Cartridge

or

Sumiko Rainier Cartridge

or 

Grado Green3 Cartridge

 

Thanks!

leemaze

None of the ones mentioned so far are good choices IMO

Aside from the tonal characteristics people try to write about

I advise paying attention to 

1. IMAGING. Both WIDE channel separation (high 20’s, even low 30’s), and TIGHT channel balance (1.0 db, even 0.5db) are needed to properly present the Phantom Imaging the engineers put in the grooves.

2. TRACKING FORCE. the published imaging specs were achieved at heavier or lighter tracking force? Lighter is preferred due to:

a. stylus life, lighter will last longer

b. lp groove wear. successfully tracking lighter will be less wear.

c. anti-skate. amount of force required is related to tracking force

3. STYLUS PROFILE, see link

4. CANTILEVER MATERIAL, see link

https://www.leson.org/choose-phono-cartridge/

compare other finds to this which tracks at 2.0g

ATVM540ML, $280.

 

agreed.  do you have an recommendations?  the turntable is a Pro-ject 1.2

I tried an Audio Technica SS445E/U with both the orignal nude stylus and an LP Gear Shibata style stylus - it was too bright and i think was too much mass with the p-mount adaptor.

want tone, texture and imaging.