You are there vs. They are there


So what is the difference?  Do I have it right?

You are there: the vocal and soundstage starts at the plane of the speakers

                         and recess backward behind the speakers plane.

They are there: The soundstage is forward into the room with the vocal

                          reproduction in your room.

 

Which would you prefer?

andy2

Yes on @spenav. We'd have to be at the recording venue and or mix down of recordings in order to arrive at some objectively determined presentation of sound stage. And then we have to consider the system recording was mixed down with, it may have entirely different presentation than our home system. There are NO means for us end users to objectively define what is the 'true' sound staging for any particular recording.

sns

There are NO means for us end users to objectively define what is the 'true' sound staging for any particular recording.

There are if you make your own recordings! With today's technology, it's never been easier to do.

@spenav + 1 Even if one made one's own recordings, hardly practical in most cases unless recording yourself or people you know, would the mic be a foot away? 10 feet away? At the back of the room? Totally different sound from each place. And would you be listening back in that same room? 

larsman

Even if one made one's own recordings, hardly practical in most cases unless recording yourself or people you know, would the mic be a foot away? 10 feet away? At the back of the room? Totally different sound from each place. And would you be listening back in that same room? 

There are at least as many variables in recording as there are in playback. Making your own recordings gives you reference that is difficult to achieve any other way.

Can someone recommend some albums they feel presents music in the 'they are here' form?

Thanks.