1. Home
  2. speakers
  3. 167922-143982

To Harbeth or not to Harbeth, That is the question...

Whether it is nobler in the ear when listening primarily to vocals and acoustic music at 55-65db max?

Whether the 30.2 or the HL5+ produces the most magical sound in a mid sized room?

These are my questions.  

I like British Speakers. Not really sure why. Respect for the the duration of their businesses?
The uppity nature of some of the makers? I enjoy the sound of Tannoy, Harbeth, Graham, ProAc, ATC.

So Friends, Romans, Harbethians please share with me you HB experiences as it relates to low volume
listening. And please explain your passion for black screw heads. 


chorus
ryder
1,769 posts
 
If I am able to give a like to akg_ca’s post, I’d do it.

Just to add, the old Monitor 30 is a far cry from the 30.1, 30.2 Anniversary and the latest 30.2 XD. If buying used, avoid the M30 at all cost as the sound is excessively shut-in, warm and thick with a severe lack in clarity and detail. Treble is rolled off and devoid of sparkle and extension.

With SHL5, the SHL5+, Anniversary or XD models are the ones to look out for. The older SHL5 does not sound as balanced as the later models.
ryder
1,769 posts
 
Proac sounds leaner with an overall livelier sound. Airier and more sparkle in the treble. The small bookshelves particularly the Tablette 10 Signature is very popular.
chorus OP
976 posts
 
Thanks to everyone for sharing their experiences. All are good to know.
I heard a friends 30.2s which were well powered and had proper peripheral gear. The room was similar in size to mine. They sounded much better than I thought they would. In the past I heard 5+s and 
thought the cabinet sound was enjoyable. ProAcs are hard to find to listen to. 
Jburdian, funny as I too have Tannoys now with dual concentric and may never switch. 
Steveashe, wow I too use a Pass INT25, Innuos Zen 3, You owned and enjoyed the Quad 63. I love quad sound but they fall apart.
tlinkie
107 posts
 


Just to add, the old Monitor 30 is a far cry from the 30.1, 30.2 Anniversary and the latest 30.2 XD. If buying used, avoid the M30 at all cost as the sound is excessively shut-in, warm and thick with a severe lack in clarity and detail. Treble is rolled off and devoid of sparkle and extension.
Yeah, the 30 series monitors from Harbeth have grown progressively more open and forward in their sound signatures. At some point they’ll be as brash as KLIPSCHes and then we’ll know they’ve gone too far j/k
avanti1960
1,744 posts
 
Harbeth C7ES3, had them for about 3 years, when fully broken in they were rich sounding without losing too much detail.  often magical sounding.  
SHL5+ for about a year, perfect for me.  Sensitive to toe in.  More transparent and neutral but still slightly rich and forgiving.  A near perfect balance of transparency and recording forgiveness with a pure, natural life like tone.  No sibilance or edginess.  Finished.  
More to discover