is the sound of vinyl due to the physical process of the turntable?

@mikelavigne ,
I don't own a single LP and really not interested. But that was THE BEST explanation you provided on how turntables work and how the sound is produced using the coil. Thanks much 🙏

Personally I think the answer is “no”. We hear in analog and by playing vinyl the music remains in the analog domain, by converting to a digital storage, we abandon the analog domain. Then by trying to reproduce that digital stored format back to analog so our ears can understand it, something gets lost. We have been trying for years and have come close with expensive DAC’s, but it is never exact, acceptable yes, but not exact.

My theory anyway.

sam here is it possible to make a dummy record like the nothing record (1978) that was cut with no music just the blank grooves and play that while i run digital audio somehow through the stylus cartridge

Tell you what. Why don't you buy a copy, try it out, and let us know how it goes?
https://www.discogs.com/No-Artist-The-Nothing-Record-Album/release/2161017