most analog sounding CDP

I believe it is a matter of personal taste.
I have heard the Reimyo under show conditions (about 1 hour)and found it too detailed/bright/clear IMHO.
You are correct in comparing it to XRCD CDs, which sound slightly overcooked IMS.
If you compare Bill Evan's Live at the Village Vanguard LP (early edition) to a XRCD you will agree with me.
Anyway the Reimyo MAY be an excellent choice, depending on taste and sinergy with the the system/room.

celebrat,
What's the list price of the Reimyo? I also have some questions about the rest of your system. Maybe I could email you if possible?

Remiyo has rubidium clock like Xrcd gear ?

Arcam cd 92,simple as the 7 letters and 2 numbers you just read.

The player that sounds the most like playing back my 2 track master reels is the TRL modified Marantz SA-14. Their mod is only $550 plus shipping. You used to be able to find a used/good condition SA-14 for around $1200. Now they're up around $1500 to $1700.

I consider open reel masters the ultimate. This said, they are what I use as a benchmark.