Are we training our ears right?


This subject comes up a lot, and degenerates into questions about what the human brain/ear mechanism is capable of hearing. 

I want to instead discuss what we should be listening for. 

Too many of us (myself often included) treat audio gear as it's own goal.  We train ourselves to hear differences for no other reason than to hear differences.   I got started ages ago in motion picture audio.  Think 1,500 seat auditoriums, not home theater.  I was constantly paying attention to dust on the film and crackling in the surround.  I often couldn't tell if a movie was good or bad because I was trying to clean the film or trace down equipment which was malfunctioning.  It's a terrible way to enjoy movies.  

Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that you can train yourself to hear differences in a fuse.  WHY would you do that?  How does that let you enjoy the 45th live recording of the Grateful Dead's Truckin' ?  The neighbor who 100% cannot hear a difference in fuses is going to enjoy your stereo better than you can. 

I'm going to argue that learning to listen to equipment this well is for manufacturers and reviewers.  Maybe we are trying to outdo them, I don't know, but it's not a road that leads us to enjoying music, is it? 

 

 

erik_squires

@ghdprentice ….as I modified my system, that kind of music would sound better... others worst

After changing components, I’m wondering how many initially focus on the positive changes, but ignore the negative ones. Also wondering if the negative overall sonic result after changing a component might be revealing of other weaknesses in their audio chain rather than just that component.

@erik_squires Let us assume, for the sake of argument, that you can train yourself to hear differences in a fuse.

Not necessarily to hear differences, but to hear sonic improvements for the money invested. 

I am a photographer by training and practice (a BFA and a MFA in photography). When I was very young, I tried to know everything about photography (and thought I did). I understood the chemistry, the optics, how camera bodies worked, and all the relevant  principles of traditional photography. When I got to art school, wise professors successfully got me to understand the difference between the means, and the end. I really don't care about photography equipment anymore - though I own great equipment, and use it everyday. I am not a gear head in that medium at all.

 

But I guess I need to express that equipment-centric view somewhere, and so audio allows me to indulge the equipment side - and that is enjoyable. But I have been trying to do for myself what my art school teachers did for me way back when - make it more about the musical art than it is about the equipment. On most days lately, I have been successful. And when I want to read about a new SPU cartridge, that's all good, too.

 

David

@dtorc "...When I got to art school, wise professors successfully got me to understand the difference between the means, and the end."

 

Great lesson. 

I've never understood why someone who isn't a reviewer or product tester listens for flaws in music. What a miserable way to try and enjoy music that is played for that reason, for the listener's enjoyment. It's a losing proposition because there will always be a flaw or a new piece of equipment that claims to be better. Hard pass.

It’s a habit  for those like me who have been intrigued with hifi sound since its inception. A lot  has changed over the years and there is good reason to stay on top of things. 
 

It’s a hard habit to break. Still, lots of different good sounds out there and worth while to understand how things work.  
 

Having said that some will take it to the extreme.   If that’s what they like to do then more power to them. 
 

It’s a dying breed to an extent though.  It’s just not as hard to get really good sound these days as it used to be.  That makes the game even harder and that makes it even more of an obsession for some.  
 

In any cases it’s not hurting anyone.  Have at it.  Whatever turns you on. 
 

Being able to hear a Dead song done 30 different ways is an interesting endeavor.  A very good hifi helps to maximize the enjoyment.