So what about powered Speakers?


Given the quality of affordable speakers like those from Bluesound I decided to try a couple of powered studio monitors.

The first was the Yorkville YSM5 Studio Monitor. These I had for a year. They were most enjoyable, but lacked some bass

The second is the Focal Alpha 65 Evo 6.5 inch Powered Studio Monitor which arrived today - so I am listening to them as I type laugh

They improved the bass performance significantly, along with a nicer top end and larger sound stage

But this is only a part of the story - you can read about my journey in this thread

Powered Speaker Approach

The impotus for this change was the realization that I had too much money tied up in my previous audio system and wondered if I could get close to it’s sound for a fraction of my previous system.

I believe I have succeded since I am finding the listening to this frugal system is providing more enjoyment than my old system did

Some may think studio monitors are for Near Field listening - true - but the Focal’s are equally as good at delivering a superb image in my listening room that is 17ft x 40ft

I think todays affordable electronics is far better than many believe it to be.

Powered speakers eliminate the need for speaker cables and since the amps are in the speaker the improvements in imaging, clarity and dynamics is significant.

Granted, this approach lacks the ablity to upgrade the amp or speakers seperately - but with speakers of this calibre, upgrading is the farthest thing from my mindangel

I would like to add that I using exceptional interconnects and power cables, which I have no doubt contribute to this wonderful sound

Hope some of you find this thread useful in your journey

Regards Steve

 

williewonka

Active speakers ("powered" can mean they're still passively configured, just with built-in amps) span quite the varieties, both in size, price and quality. If you're more of an entrepreneur and don't mind diving into the rabbit hole of doing filter settings by yourself, you go outboard active and get to choose the components just as you see fit - same as you would passively. No excuses here; get familiar with what active can do with separates by your own hands and abilities, and without the bloody power and quality draining complex, passive filters in between. 

Going by the OP's subject however, i.e.: bundled active speakers, imagine finding the "balls to the wall" active filter-amp-speaker (and possibly DAC in addition) system that suits your ears and dreams and that has the benefit of providing for a much improved amp-to-driver interface, and then forget about it and start concentrating on improving everything around it from the basis of a much more resolving and transparent (active) speaker system with a major bottleneck less to deal with.

Sometimes you get the feeling that the conservative, passively configured speakers only folks believe active speakers don't give you the opportunity to tweak the system in which they're implemented - that is, as if it's a negative - but it's actually more about the blessing of not having to deal with tweaking in the primary area of amp-to-driver interfacing (something that, conversely, would be necessitated from a passive context, though to a much lesser outcome), and instead being able to focus on fine tuning from said better, active outset. For those who don't believe an active speaker context can be true high-end and everything you want it to be, dig a little deeper.  

Ad nauseam diatribe on this site.  More respected opinions would come from those who have lived for some years with active speakers.  I own ATC 19A, 40A and 50A floor standers.  The 19s and 40s for over 15 years.  No failures.  I'm sure they could fail.  But then near anything can.

If one does not like actives for whatever reasons previously listed, then by all means do not purchase them.  They are not for you.  But the arguments against, oft  by non-owners, rings a bit hollow.  I don't do missionary work and couldn't care less about what occupies others homes.  Love them or stay away.  That's the beauty.  We all get to choose which sandbox we want to play in.

@zlone 

I doubt it can get to the level of a truly great system.

If you did get to the true high end and commensurate cost

It's subjective because you know you're hearing what the designers intended with the active amps. Obviously, most here don't like class D and want some artificial tricks from an amp. But I think KEF is class A + D.

I agree with @studio1 If I were to venture into that realm, ATC would be at the top of my list. Would be interesting trying some different tube preamps with them.

If one can't get a "truly great system" using active speakers, then that means that most of the recording studios that make our music are doing it wrong. wink