My digital side sounds excellent, no complaints. Aurender N200, Teac 701t and Lab 12 DAC 1 Ref.
I just upgraded my Sota to a new Sota with a Dynavector XX2 mkII and now it's hard NOT to want to listen to vinyl. I should have spent $$$ on a great cartridge a long time ago.
As I listen and compare my analog /digital chain I think it's clear to me that you are actually preferring the way the hardware "sounds" than the source with LPs. If that makes sense. That plus the mastering may make one lean toward vinyl.
Either way I enjoy and use all formats.

