I was at a high end shoot out with different digital sources on top end Wilson speakers and CH precision electronics and Shunyata cables that may have cost more than my entire system. The verdict was Cd sounded the best, ripped files were second and streaming was last. This was from the exact same sourced music. It was interesting since the digital trail can be compromised it's travel.
Does anyone have a digital system that is as involving as their analogue front end?
I have a good analogue front end. Not stratuspherically good but good enough for this comparison. VPI Prime Signature 21 turntable, Pass Labs XP-25 pono preamp, Pass Labs XP-30 preamp and Hovland Radia amp. It has a lovely, very involving sound. On the right recording, I just drop everythng and am drawn in to listen.
My streamer, on the other hand, is decent but not spectacular. It is better than my CD player, but it is not jaw-dropping like my analogue front-end. My question is this: does anyone have a high-end, tier-one streamer (dCS Bartok Apex, Lumin X2, or something like them) that can rival a good analogue system?
- ...
- 295 posts total
@goose I’m not surprised. |
I have compared a well-recorded CD played through my Meitner MA3 DAC to a well-recorded streamed recording through the Meitner. The streamed recording sounds more fleshed out, the individual notes are more resonant. The CD is thinner, but its transcient attacks sound better defined. Is that because the music sounds thinner? I don't know. I think, though, that some recordings I would rather play streamed and others on CD. One example of what I consider a well-recorded album is Cassandra Wilson's "Blue Light 'Till Dawn." I have it on vinyl also, and that is the best of all worlds. The sound is fleshed out as well as the attacks. I don't think I'll ever have enough money to purchase a streamer that sounds better than my analogue front end. |
@audio-b-dog I have that CD, it is also ripped to SSD, and I got the blue note vinyl mastered by Kevin Gray. I only have my buddy’s old Audio Research player now that I used as both player and transport. The player is leaving my system soon. I have listened to this album and yeah the CD sounds cleaner but slightly leaner. Vinyl sounds warm and full bodied. Streaming is somewhere in between. |
What I can say aobut "Blue Light 'Till Dawn" is that it is among the best-sounding recordings that I've heard streamed. I think it streams at 24/96 which also makes a difference. I can tell when something is streaming at 16/44. It's a flatter sound. My analogue front end is very transparent. Before I purchased the Pass Labs XP-25 and XP-30, I played analogue through an ARC PH-7 (the first ARC phono stage to use trickle-down technology from the Reference series) and an ARC Ref. 3 preamp. They had a slightly more "musical" sound than the Pass Labs which are more "transparent." I would say extremely transparent unless you get up into the uber-expensive stuff. Anyway, I have other good equipment to compare to what I'm now using. I believe that the streaming version of "Blue Light" is a very high-end recording because it sounds so good. The CD also sounds very good. Better than almost all my other CDs. I think we're as close to apples to apples as we can get on this conmparison. BTW, I use a McCormack UDP-1 as a transport. It used premier parts 25 years ago, and although those parts are a generation old, I think they still put out a solid 16/44 signal. Especially since I purchased the more expensive coax cable. Interesting to compare these things. Everybody I know would think I'm crazy if I told them I spend time and energy on such comparisons, but I do have various interests to keep me awake. |
- 295 posts total

