Often times bass response issues are because of room nodes which can be corrected by dialing in the peaks in the response.
Agree with @jrareform you may be sitting in a null. Bass is tricky and if you have yet to crawl on your floor (military crawl), you will know what you are missing if and when you find it.
You may want to start with placing your speakers straight ahead (no toe-in).
Not knowing what dampening material is on your first reflection point, but 4-inch would be recommended- preferably with Owens-Corning 703- and not foam or most of what one gets from GK or ATS and others.
You may also want to try the diffusers you have on the back wall and place them at the first reflection point, or just underneath your current first reflection material.

