I finally looked at your JBL 4349's (sorry I didn't look them up earlier)
I think your problem, with them, is they are only 2 way. JBL includes level controls like they used to, however, for the 2 way models, they only alter the tweeter, there is no midrange.
I think you need a 3 way speaker, with level controls for both the midrange and the tweeter.
Normally, you adjust them in your space, to get close to flat frequency response, and finally adjust for your personal preference
For you, listening at low volumes, I think the secret will be to reduce the midrange control (relative to the woofer), so when you get down to (or up to) say 53 db, your 'curve' will automatically have more bass than 'flat'.
After a few days, then adjust the tweeter, for less or more as per personal taste.
Like their Model 4312G
It has separate controls for the midrange and for the tweeter. Nicely, they are on the front, my AR-2ax are on the back.
////////////////////////////////////
Other makers, vintage or current include midrange level controls which I believe is the solution.
IF/when playing at higher volumes, front controls, then it's easy to turn the mids back up to 'normal'.
Sum it up: cut the mids rather than boost the bass.

