"Satisfying" is not settling


The AI pioneer, cognitive psychologist, and Nobel Prize-winning economist Herbert Simon is known for an insight that is crucially relevant to sufferers from audiophilia nervosa. Captured in the coinage “satisficing” (a synthesis of “satisfy” and “suffice”), he insists on a version of the cliché “The Best is the enemy of the Good.” For most decisions, people just can’t hope to wade through the overwhelming number of choices available to them in modern consumer societies—by one estimate, consumer options in modern economies exceed those of preindustrial societies by a factor of 100 million! This phenomenon is visible everywhere, and nowhere more conpicuously than in the audio equipment market.  

This sort of superabundance, multiplied by social media, in everything from toilet paper to dating choices, creates a kind of self-perpetuating anxiety that one could do better. As a result, as an opinion piece in today’s NYTimes puts it, “Maximizers tend to be less satisfied with their decisions and their lives. They are typically less happy, more prone to regret and more likely to compare themselves endlessly with others.” Sound familiar? Searching for the best can often just be the wrong goal; the certainty that something better must be out there robs the present experience of its value. We neglect our love of the music because of some perceived imperfection in our technologies of reproduction.

Am I only speaking for myself? “The absolute sound” should not be the goal. It’s not only unreachable for so many reasons—more to the point, it’s a trap that seduces us with shiny and expensive distractions. Satisficing is not settling. Rather, it’s a matter of remembering that the technology is a tool, a means to an end, not an end in itself.

snilf

The movie "Moscow on the Hudson", Robin Williams faints when he walks into the coffee aisle at a grocery store.

For me, "good enough" is...

Happy listening.

I guess the bottom line is that the problem is with the individual and not society. Audio nervosa really isnt a real thing in my opinion. And these type of exercises inevitably end up with some sort of message related to economic and social awareness. If you want something and can afford it buy it with no further thought required. 

I feel the same way about know-it-all-ism. Everyone is an individual, and every simpleton is a genius unto themselves.

I guess we all move on yes listening to AM radio.Then got my mother Webco record player and bought 45 ....theu sounded great.I wasn't allowed to used my stepfather Motorola console stereo  with reverb and 12 in speakers...we he was out of the house ,I would play my albums and the sound was outrageous. I now havd so much vintage stereo equipment that I can open a store  lps,cds,cassettes, RtoR....forget about it ....

Or every genius is limited to one area of expertise and a simpleton in all others.

 

@snilf 

You make an absolutely critical point.

I recently sent back Linn’s new and extremely expensive Klimax Radikal for the LP12. Yes, does amazing things and makes vinyl sound so much better in many ways. However, I am happier with my system than I have been for long time particularly with digital without the performance enhancing new Klimax Radikal.

The reason for my satisfaction is simple. It’s not that the Klimax Radikal isn’t excellent. It is and I wouldn’t hesitate to buy it if I had the cash available.

The reason I’m happy is because I have recently been looking at more fundamental things like vibration control and trying to mitigate against interference and noise. This has involved very small expenditure on things like digital cables, but mainly attention to detail and rearranging digital components.

What is important is to remove the effect of nasties such as bass resonances, digital glare and reflections on the sound. This turns out to be more fundamental than the undoubted gains that can come from expensive upgrades.

Clearly it’s in the interests of retailers to see the answer to every problem as an expensive upgrade. I am not saying that I might not be tempted by such upgrades in future. These have their place, but they are not necessarily where true satisfaction lies.