Turntable Causes Speaker Cones To Excessively Move Rapidly


I have a Technics 1200G turntable, Luxman 595, and I use MM carts. For some reason, when I play my turntable I see my sub woofer cone (REL sub) and my Focal Sopra N1 cones move violently. There is a subsonic filter on it where helps cut down on it. But I am wondering... does anyone else have this issue?

If I didn’t have the subsonic filter would the violent moving of my cones damage my speakers? I ran it for about 2 hours total of turntable music before I noticed. 

Not a issue with my streamer... they stay almost perfectly still. Just with turntable. 

dman777

Remove dust cover, place the player on isoacoustics zazen 2 or equivalent. That's what I did

If you can, put the TT on the floor to test as it is most likely the stand it's on.

Hello Dman777,

I had that same experience with my Rel subwoofers cavitating rather violently when playing analog only. Most of the recommendations I received focused on isolating my turntable. After doing all the isolation options, upgrading my tonearm, changing phono cartridges, upgrading the subs, changing the turntable platter bearing it turned out to be a turntable motor issue where the screws affixing the motor to the plinth had somehow not been tightened. 

Make sure your turntable assembly is torqued down properly. Hope this helps you.

Yogiboy appropriately mentioned tonearm / cartridge mismatch as the most likely culprit. I agree. Your response assumes the vendor would not sell you a mismatched combination, but that may not be true.

Look up the effective mass of your tonearm as well as the rated compliance of your cartridge. Go to vinylengine.com, open a free account, and surf to their cartridge resonance evaluator. This will calculate your resonant frequency. The higher the compliance, the lower the resonant frequency on any given tonearm.

As an owner of a Technics TT with an aluminum arm, the arm mass can be pretty high. I had the same problem running a Shure V15-III. The problem resolved when I installed an Ortofon Concord, which has a lower compliance AND lowered the effective tonearm mass (no headshell or fastener mass).

All "rumble" or "subsonic" filters are not alike.  AND, both your subwoofer and speakers are vented...which makes them susceptible to noise generated by normal record playback at frequencies below their "cutoff point"...tuned resonance frequency,  For the REL this is probably around 20Hz, and for the Sopra 1s around 50Hz...so both are wide open to oscilate when fed  0-12Hz.  The Lux filter is probably 6dB/oct below 20Hz.  You need a steeper filter.  This can be obtained with an outboard phono preamp whose design inludes a sharp filter.  The other solution is to use sealed box speakers and subwoofers that are "loaded" to roll off below their resonance frequency.