Consider if you will...the two formats can just be different representations of musical content. I use a dCS Bartok and have top all tube, class A, amplification from Conrad-Johnson. Table is a Rega Planar 10 with their very good cart. Wilson speakers. Listen primarily to Jazz.
Just this morning I was comparing my main tube amplifier with a Pass Labs Class A amp. The digital was great and the analog good but not as much. What's wrong here?
What I realized later in the day is that I listen to Qobuz and Roon streams for different musical aspects than My LPs. The digital world allows their recordings to emphasize the unique sounds of very low base, electronic sound effects, super shimmering highs, specifically placed instruments, deep soundstage... all attention getters for your ears.
A well recorded LP has a realistic and comfortable quality that digital doesn't.
If you are used to one, the other sounds a bit contrived or not quite right. One other aspect to consider. System set up. If I were into my analog world as I am the digital, my speaker placement would change as I would not be chasing stage debth, fine detail and those unique sounds anymore. But... it's all good and the music is great.