Making your room more square is going to create other issues with your bass response especially. Rectangular rooms are always better. It may wind up working perfectly for you somehow. But my opinion is that it isn't the recording if it's consistent. Most modern recordings are mastered fairly flat in the bass response. Most likely your room nodes are causing big nulls in your frequency response in your sub bass.
Closing off the room sounded great until I heard you're turning it into basically a square. Keep us posted. If the response is the same or worse, you will most likely need 3 or 4 subs in that configuration if you want a flattish response. Sometimes two can do it though especially if you run your towers full range but it's nice to take the sub energy off your towers. I've found that by doing that it makes them sound better because those 8" drivers aren't having to produce 20 hz etc. Best of luck!

