I’ll share a resent experience with having purchased 2 items made by the same manufacturer but bought from 2 different dealers.
Event #1, I ordered a McIntosh MT10 Turntable on December 15, 2025 from my local high-end audio dealer. I took delivery of the MT10 on January 17, 2026. The shop did the initial setup in-house, so after picking up the unit, I unboxed the turntable and began to play it. 4 weeks later, doing my due diligence to prepare an LP for playing, I cued up the tonearm, released the tonearm lever, it lowered down onto the record and suddenly to my surprise, the tonearm skates off the record. (This was a first in my over 60 years of being an audiophile). Thinking that I made a mistake I cued-up the tonearm in alignment with the record only to see it skate off the record a second time. Then I noticed that the stylus was missing and that tiny component was laying on the top of the audio cabinet having been flung there when it broke away from the cartridge. (Note: The MT10’s tonearm lever doesn’t allow manually placing the tonearm down to the record initially, it pneumatically lowers the tonearm once the tonearm lever reaches it’s lowest point, so it’s not like I dropped the tonearm down on the record breaking the stylus.)
I called my audio dealer to report that the stylus had broken away from the cartridge. I described to the tech at the shop my preparation steps and the results, his conclusion was that, “It must be operator error that broke the stylus and that he could sell me a new one with no concessions regarding being under manufacturers warranty. This was on a Saturday, I told him that I would call the owner on their next business day to hopefully get a better result. On their next business day, Tuesday, I received a phone call from the tech-salesman that actually sold me the MT10. He informed me that he got a scenario of my call on Saturday with his colleague. I informed him that in addition to my call on Saturday with his colleague, I called McIntosh the day before (Monday) and they were reviewing my situation and issued me an AR #. He said that he would send an email to McIntosh Labs Service Department to advocate for a replacement and to express to McIntosh that I was a loyal customer with a complete system made of their components (my system can be viewed on this forum)… I never heard back from McIntosh. However, McIntosh sent a replacement cartridge to my local audio shop on my behalf and the shop voluntarily opted to come to my house to reinstall and calibrate the new cartridge. Now I thought that was what customer service is supposed to be like! Albeit, my first contact with both the dealer’s shop and McIntosh was disappointing…
Event #2 with yet another McIntosh product, ie; an MP100 Phono Preamp which was ordered around the same time as the MT10 and was already installed in my system previously, before the stylus incident, which had an electronic high-pitched sound that could be heard faintly from the cabinet installed unit but also through the left speaker once the music stopped playing. I asked this forum’s members for help diagnosing the problem and got good suggestions to diagnose and solve the problem. I took all of the troubleshooting advice and did a step by step process from each method, with no joy! So, I called Crutchfield (where I ordered the unit from) to be informed that their 60 day return policy had expired, it was day 64 from receiving it. Okay, so I contacted McIntosh, the unit still being under it’s, new product 3-year warranty and was given 3 options to resolve my issue with the phono preamp, 1) Call Crutchfield for a replacement (I explained why that wasn’t an option 2) Send the unit to McIntosh’s Service Department, where I was informed that servicing the unit could take 4 to 6 months and could possibly take as long as 1-1/2 years to get it back to me. 3) I could take it to an authorized repair shop that’s 70 miles from where I live, 4) Take the unit to the only other authorized shop in my area that was 65 miles in the other direction. I live in the San Francisco Bay Area and I live practically equal distance from both authorized shops however, both traffic corridors are two of the worst in the country!! At no time did McIntosh offer to replace the defective unit with another new unit…
Having gotten those alternatives from McIntosh I called Crutchfield again with McIntosh’s solutions and a manager at Crutchfield granted me an exception to their 60 day return policy. I returned the old unit to Crutchfield, they sent me a new MP100 that works fine in my system…Problem solved!
I never expect repair or replacement coverage on pre-owned/used gear past the company’s claim of good working condition period. But when it comes to buying new gear I think there should be a better standard…
Like someone mention in this stream, I guess we all should consider before purchasing, what servicing or repair polices and or methods we’re willing to go along with.
So KUDOS to companies like CRUTCHFIELD, and maybe not so much for the big guys like McIntosh…