Can you help me decide between these two?


I have asked and all said seek a new turntable. I am using a Technics SL-Q3. I have come to these two choices. Michell Tecnodec or Acoustic Signature Primus. can you provide info as to which? Obviously buying both used. I do have a Benz SL cartridge but that I may or may not use. 

dpm2340

I cannot help, but curiosity made me ask my browser (brave, no pop-ups) and these are the AI quickies I got, others with direct knowledge of them can add to this I imagine.

Mitchell

The Michell TecnoDec is an entry-level reference turntable from Michell Engineering that incorporates high-end technologies typically found in more expensive models, such as the GyroDec.  It features an unsuspended solid-plinth design with Pure Sorbothane feet for vibration isolation, an impedance-matched platter for neutral sound characteristics, and a free-standing motor unit machined from aircraft-grade aluminum to minimize vibration transfer via the drive belt alone. 

Key technical specifications and features include:

  • Inverted Oil Circulating Main Bearing: Uses a modified Archimedean screw to draw oil from a base reservoir to the top thrust ball, ensuring continuous lubrication and reduced noise. 

  • Tonearm Options: Typically equipped with the Michell T2 tonearm (based on Rega designs) or available with Technoarm/Origin Live options; cartridges are often sold separately or in packages. 

  • Dimensions49cm width31cm depth8.5cm height, and 4.6kg weight

  • Price: Retail prices generally range from $2,200 to $2,600 USD or £2,000 GBP, depending on the bundle and retailer.

The turntable is designed for minimal setup and maintenance, offering a low noise floor and high musicality, positioning it as a formidable performer and significant value in the high-end vinyl market. 

Acoustic

The Acoustic Signature Primus is the German manufacturer’s entry-level belt-drive turntable, designed to deliver high-end performance with Teutonic Engineering precision.  It features a heavy 4.5 kg aluminum platter mounted on a proprietary Tidorfolon bearing (backed by a 10-year warranty) and is driven by a DC motor with an external power supply for stability. 

The turntable is available in two main configurations:

  • With RB 202 Tonearm: A modified British tonearm paired with an Ortofon 2M Red cartridge, originally launched at an RRP of £1295

  • With TA-500 Tonearm: Acoustic Signature’s first fully in-house tonearm, featuring a dual carbon tube for superior damping and stiffness. 

Constructed from a rigid MDF and chipwood sandwich chassis, the Primus focuses on mechanical quality over gimmicks.  While it was a popular model for audiophiles seeking German build quality at an accessible price point, it is now classified as a discontinued product and is primarily available on the secondary market or through remaining stock retailers. 

Let me help you by asking a few questions.  What is the Technics missing that you are hoping to find in a new turntable?  Perhaps make a short list of things.  Now thinking about each of the turntables you are considering, what do you like about it?  What are it's shortfalls?  Finally, match up your first list with the list of pros and cons for each of the TTs you are considering to see which one, if either, better matches your wants.  If neither satisfies your desires adequately, consider your budget.  Perhaps it would be best to be patient until a better option comes along.  In the class of TT you are looking at there are excellent options from several companies.  To name a few:  Music Hall, Teac, Rega, Dual, Pro-ject, Yamaha.  Take your time.  Pay special attention to the ergonomics of the TT under consideration.  How does it look and feel to you when you play records?  This might be the single most important consideration of all when buying a turntable regardless of price.  Let us know your progress.

My choice would be to keep the Technics SL-Q3. 

Personally I find myself deviating more and more from tapes and records to streaming only.  And I started using both (tapes and records) when I was 6-7 years old - (ab)using my father's stereo.  So I have a huge emotional connection to both formats - but convenience of streaming is winning over me.