Recommend a turntable!

Given the two turntables you own, not just any run of the mill DD is going to measure up. I would look for a well cared for Denon DP75 or 80 based turntable. 

If you are adventurous you could buy the drive unit, and then look for a builder for the plinth, or if you are a bit handy you can turn a large cutting board or butcher block into a plinth with a router or jig saw and some patience. Then source your own arm. 

These tables come in various condition on Ebay also. I did locate a DP80 that had its electronics refreshed for a reasonable price. Bought from this seller DENON DP-80 Quartz turntable repaired basic operation confirmed good beautiful | eBay

Here is the unit I received. 

With your budget, by far and away you should go with the Pioneer PLX1000.  I bought one recently on a whim, mounted an Audio Technica AT-VM95SH and I have been binging on LP's the last few weeks.  Can't recommend this combo highly enough!

The table is 30# for the love of Pete!  It is just a pleasure to use, great tactile qualities and very quiet, solid table.

Never had a Shibata stylus before.  No more ellipticals for me.  Detailed, organic, dimensional. quiet, all at a bargain price.

The table retails for almost $900 now thanks to all these damn tariffs.  But, look for coupon codes.  I lucked out and scored on for under $700.  Even at normal retail, the table is well worth $900.

This one is overpriced, a nice one just sold for $650. I got one and set it up for a friend, we both think it is a cut above, as well as so easy to use.

https://reverb.com/item/94401061-mitsubishi-lt20-linear-tracking-turntable-in-excellent-condition-serviced-1980-s

If it appeals to you, and not in a hurry, just go to hifishark.com, search mitsubishi direct drive turntable, sort by first seen, new first,

LT30; LT20, ... other models, some black or gray, some wood grain, but a skin, not veneer, still they look nice,

Linear tracking, removable headshell, any 1/2" mount cartridge. 

OP

Technics SL-50C, $799.

Technics SL-50C (Terra cotta) Manual direct-drive turntable with built-in phono preamp (Terra cotta) at Crutchfield

it has a switchable phono pre-amp

Also Linear Tracking, and Programmable, I had one in my second system, used it for awhile in my main system, loaned it to 3 audiophile friends, we all agreed, it plays and sounds terrific. I gave it to my son, glad I did, but I miss it.

P mount cartridge, easy to change, no alignment or anti-skate needed, and they make P mount cartridges with advanced stylus shapes, I got one with Shibata.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/127817598043?mkrid=711-53200-19255-0&campid=5338381866&toolid=10001&customid=6f442ad6-3c0d-11f1-9483-313330333831