Tube Phono Stage Recommendations


Hey,

Lately I been getting the itch to try a tube phono stage.

So, I wanted to reach out to get some recommendations.

Budget would be $2K or lower.

I am aware of the following that usually get good reviews and recommendations:

- Hagerman Trumpet MC
- Decware ZP3 (Looks like a real hardcore tube phono stage)
- Tavish (although not sure if they are producing at the moment)
- Black Ice Audio
- Schiit STJARNA
 

These are some that I am not really considering:

- Pro-Ject
- EAT
 

Any others that can be recommended that maybe I am not aware of?

Thanks

jay73

@jay73 

look into a Sun valley Audio SV-EQ1616D 

I heard a demo in a show, and it allows the user flexibility in tuning the users Phono cartridge to the phono preamp. Certain Stereophile reviewer have this model as their reference phono pre-amps. I know that in discussion, it was offered as a "kit" but Victor Chung of vkmusic can have this built for you at a reasonable cost. 

its available at vkmusic.ca

at higher price points, I will suggest the Chinook or the Zesto spirit. but look first at the Sun valley Phono pre-amps.

 

 

Thanks to everyone for their recommendations so far!

I am looking through them all.

I did have another question since we are on the topic of Phono Preamps and I did not want to create a whole new thrread.

At the moment, I have a Sim Audio Moon 110lp v2 phono preamp.

Another thing that  I have been thinking about is perhaps adding a LPS to it, like a Sbooster or Ifi Power Elite.

Any thoughts on that?

If there are any improvements, do you think it would be worth it?

Thanks

Have the Hagerman. Great phono pre. My only suggestion is to upgrade the power supply before you spend a bunch of money on better tubes. The PS makes a WAY bigger difference in the sound.

You have a Vincent Amp.  Consider the Vincent PHO-500 for around $500.  From what I’ve read, it gets good reviews and is quiet. Here are it’s primary features: 

  • A fully isolated external power supply for dramatically lower noise
  • MM/MC compatibility with proper loading options
  • A 24/96 USB recording interface (unique in this price class)
  • A heavier, better‑shielded chassis

Noise floor becomes the defining factor under $2,000—especially with low‑output MC cartridges. Designs with external power supplies (Vincent PHO‑500) or fully separated MM/MC circuits tend to outperform more “feature‑packed” units because they avoid injecting noise into the gain stages.

 

There was also a PHO-8 (discontinued) which got good reviews from Stereophile that perhaps can be found used.  (I actually own a PHO-8, but have never used it.  So, I can’t comment beyond what I’ve read.)  

Otherwise, if you can find a BAT VK-P5 which can be had used under $2k and would move your phono stage game into another universe.  Here’re some of its features:

    • Fully differential, dual‑mono tube phono stage
    • Eight triodes in a high‑voltage, zero‑feedback topology
    • Massive power supply with choke regulation
    • Designed for low‑output MC cartridges
    • True high‑end architecture: large transformers, film caps, discrete regulation, point‑to‑point wiring in critical paths

. . .and it could be upgraded to improve its already excellent performance.  

Here’s the AI comparison against the BAT VK-P5: 

Model Topology Noise Floor MC Handling Sonic Character Comparison vs VK-P5
Hagerman Trumpet MC All-tube gain + JFET MC front end Very low for tubes Excellent (JFET headamp) Big, open, harmonically rich Closest competitor; still less authority and scale
Decware ZP3 Pure tube, MM-only Very low but MM-only Needs SUT Warm, holographic, vintage-tube magic Beautiful but not in VK-P5’s league; limited by MM-only
Tavish Hybrid tube/JFET Low Good (Adagio best) Neutral-warm, clean, refined Strong value; not the dynamic equal of VK-P5
Black Ice Audio Tube/solid-state hybrid Moderate Good Smooth, euphonic, forgiving Fun but mid-fi; lacks resolution and headroom
Schiit Stjarna Fully discrete solid-state Very low Excellent Neutral, fast, modern Technically clean but lacks tube dimensionality of VK-P5