OP,
You will get more musical sound with an Audio Research preamp... holographic without being shiny like it is with the Luxman. The character from the X and XA amps is different. As an aside, turning the nob is not a good indicator of power requirements... very long story. Anyway. Slam is a somewhat artificial characteristic created by a bit lean and powerful solid state amps... it doesn't happen in the real world. XA is a more natural and musical and as such presents music this way. I would drop in your speakers and expected preamp in to and AI and ask for sonic characteristics you can expect from different X an XA amps. It is usually pretty good.
You will get what you want from either of these choices. Luxman attains its imaging from emphasis on treble making the somewhat shiny and unnatural sounding. This equipment is much higher caliber and more natural and musical sounding. I'd go XA... although I went one step further with an Audio Research Ref 160 tube amp. Way better, more natural an musical than any of the Pass amps.

