Seeking best sounding El-34 tubes for my power amplifier


I have a 150 watt monoblocks  amplifiers made by Thor Audio. Thor Audio is out of business for quite a few years. Each 150 watt monoblock is round and has 8 El-34 output tubes on each monoblock for a total of 16 tubes.  I currently have Sovtek tubes. Any suggestions would be appreciated. Thank you. 

kjl1065

chickenoregg, I have an older Avatar SE.

Kevin of VAC recommended vintage Mullard EL34 and vintage Sylvania 12AU7, and that’s what I currently use, Mullards XF2 and Sylvania long black plates from 50s. For preamp I have Mullard long narrow plates, though he didn’t mention them and suggested his selected stock Chinese. 

I also tried early and late 50s RCA black plates 12AU7. Early 50s RCA sounded almost exactly as the Sylvania, great, but Sylvania were a touch better, though. Late 50s RCA were significantly worse than both, a bit dark and closed in, but not bad.

I did first have Svetlana Winged C EL34. Not a bad sound but the Mullards are so much better.

I would be surprised to hear, if someone can find easily 16 octad matched NOS well performing tubes! 

Yeah, it would probably take time, and perhaps not exactly NOS, just that test NOS.

I I've had a Lectron JH-50 amp since 1992 and throughout the years, I tried whatever EL-34 tubes were available. However, I've never tried any NOS tubes.

I've used a lot of Sovtek and Electro-Harmonix tubes because of their liveliness. I've heard criticism about the (weak) bass they produce but I don't listen to the music that way and that never bothered me. Both tubes are highly reliable and last a long time. By the way, bias on my amp is on a lower side.

At some point, I started to buy Svetlana, and I liked them too, even though they sounded different (more mellow and warm). Their reliability is also excellent.

I agree with people above who praise Psvane PHI - I think these are excellent tubes in my system. 

About a year ago, I ordered Shuguang 6CA7-T directly from their factory store (AliExpress). I replaced Psvane with these and never went back. They produce a slightly warm (not like Svetlana), very clean, transparent and detailed sound throughout the whole spectrum. They produce pinpoint imaging, and they are very dynamic, dimensional, and atmospheric. I think Psvane tubes sound very similar and this is why I like them both more than any other tubes I've ever tried. To me, Psvane and Shuguang tubes sound good with any type of music. However, I cannot evaluate their reliability. 

I have a tube tester, and I do not wait until a tube dies - I replace tubes when they become weak. All Sovtek, Electro-Harmonix, and Svetlana tubes I have ever bought were tested and matched and I have never lost any of them. No other tubes could match reliability of these 3 in my system.

I hope this helps.

 

   

I prefer 6CA7 over EL34. More dynamic, better bass and upper treble, and a little more power.

Every EL34 amp might not improve with 6CA7s, but it worked in several amps I've tried.