Vacuum Tube Snake Oil Salesmen


Just a mini rant to complain about vacuum tube suppliers (not all but most) and their false advertising.

I ordered a set of 4 matched 2A3 Acme tubes direct from PSVane for my Woo Audio WA33 as an upgrade. They cost close to $1k all together.

When I got them I checked on my MaxiMatcher2. The boxes said 65mA but with correct operating voltage and bias set on the tester I could only get 2 of them up to 43mA. One other read 39mA. And the last one was an internal fault short which could have damaged my amp had I not checked them.

I asked to return one "Matched" set for replacement. The PSVane customer service would only offer to send me one tube and not a matched pair. They would not pay return shipping to return one set. Instead they demanded I smash the bad tube and send them a picture. Has anyone ever smashed a large vacuum tube with a hammer and seen where all the pieces of glass fly to? I said no way. I will throw it out or return it but I am not going to risk cutting my hand doing that. So they refused to send a replacement. 

While I had the Maximatcher out I decided to go thru some other tubes I had in my spares box to check them (purchased before I had the tube tester). I could not believe the results. Some tubes matched by well known vendors were off by as much as 30% from each other.

It is really a good investment to get a tube tester if you will be a regular user of tube amps. 

If you must buy PSVane then get them from Amazon and not direct so you have some safety to return them.

 

calieng

If you place a towel over the tube and then smash it with the hammer, all the pieces will stay together. Do this in a used Amazon delivery 📦 box that way when you’re done you can just throw it all away no mess

I would only worry about a shorted tube, matching tubes should only be done in the equipment it is used in. I don't think the maximatcher even has a regulated supply.

Yes the shorted tube was the main concern.

For 2A3 you can only test one tube at a time due to the limitations of the tester so it should be reasonably accurate. I doubt it would be off more than a couple mA. Certainly not 20mA or more deviation from what is listed on the tube boxes.

At 325V plate and -60V bias I had 34mA and -45V bias was 43mA. The specs for 2A3 are 80mA when 300V plate and -62V bias. At 250V plate and -45V bias it should be 60mA. So the tubes are way off spec.

The Maximatcher II can handle four KT tubes at a time. I was testing one 2A3 at a time so I doubt I dropped the voltage much if any.

Suggestion, place condemned tube in a paper shopping bag and smash with wooden or plastic hammer handle. 
Enjoy the music.