@bdp24 yes, clearly the song would be different. I actually like the song, but then again, I like the movie "Gone With the Wind". However, both present the South and the Civil War in a problematic light. All I am arguing is that you should take the song within the context of a decades long movement within the United States to paint the South and the Confederacy in a favorable light and as such downplay the evil at its core. It's hard for me to comprehend but it's 2023 and a major political party leader wants to teach children that slavery was beneficial to the enslaved.
And in no way am I accusing you of anything but being the world's biggest The Band fan.

