I forgot to mention this but honestly DIYaudio is a much better place for speaker building questions than Audiogon. Lots of builders with first hand experience into all sorts of designs.
Best of luck,
Erik
Free air resonance
Hello all,
Is a speaker with a free air resonance of 25 hz meaningfully different from one with a free air resonance of 38 hz?
Specifically: is the one at 25 hz low enough to be in a sealed enclosure, as opposed to the one at 38 hz which most likely/definitely should be in a ported enclosure? And why?
Thank you in advance …
@unreceivedogma , That is exactly the point. You want as little baffle showing as possible. I just finished building new subwoofers, They are 30 inch long, 15" in diameter with a 12" driver stuck in both ends. The construct is easy. I did it for different reasons as subwoofers do not image. |
@mijostyn +2 @mahgister +1 @erik_squires This has been a fascinating read and I am impressed with all the sharing of knowledge. I just joined because (to me) I have an odd question and don't know how to start a new thread, and also because it ties into this thread. I have an 18" driver (normally I don't go beyond 15", but this has a BL 31, so I figured I had adequate cone control), and maintains a SPL of 96+dB between 100Hz and its Fs 38, which is my relevant range for this sub. The curious thing is that its free-air response is flat enough that it stays above 93dB beyond its Fs and down to 25Hz, and I would like to build a cabinet that takes advantage of this, a cabinet that can extend its response from 38 to 25. Its Vas calls for a 4.13 cu.ft. cabinet, and its compliance is fairly stiff with a Cms of 0.05mm/N. With its Qts right at 0.40 I'm torn between a ported and a sealed. It moves a lot of air with a Vd at 1286 cc, and of course, that's without much excursion. So, my question is two fold: how can I build a cabinet to drive the response down to 25Hz? And if so, does the cone stiffness hinder or help, and how can I take advantage of the driver's properties? Any help would be appreciated! |
@hsbrock Really you need a cabinet simulator and to spend more time at DIYaudio. :) |