LS50 + Sub Or Floorstander?


I’ve been happy with my LS50s from the day I got them. But there’s no getting around the fact that they are small bookshelf speakers. While bookshelves undoubtedly have their advantages (ease of placement, imaging, coherence), I find myself thirsting for the bass and sense of a floorstander. Particularly the bass.

I’ve been preparing myself for the thoroughly enjoyable task of making my rounds of NYC’s stereo stores, listening to some of the many well-received floorstanders in the $3,000 range. Maybe even blow the doors out on a pair of Proac DT8s.

But is that the best way to go? What if I add a subwoofer(s)? That will solve my bass problems, right? Probably better than most floorstanders. But will it give me the sense of big, orchestral scale that I associate with floorstanders? (I don’t listen to a lot of orchestras but I still want a sense of scale.)

I listen to indie rock and jazz, 66/33. (One percent for Sinatra.) My room is a thoroughly medium sized 15x20. I think it would be perfectly happy with a small floorstander and none that I’ve read about top 40 inches.

After all is said and done, new cables are bought, the LS50s are sold, etc., the bookshelf plus sub configuration will be significantly cheaper than the floorstander. No small consideration.

I’d much rather make this decision based on first-hand listening but I don’t think that will be possible. I’ve never heard of anyone auditioning a subwoofer, probably because of the difficulty of setting it up properly. So I need all the help I can get. 

Thanking you in advance.

paul6001

I was/am in the same boat, trying to match a sub to 2 monitors.

It really depends on your music choices, 4 out 5 times, my subwoofer doesn't add much to the overall sound quality and image

You can be successful either way. I think a main goal with adding a subwoofer is to even out the bass response. To do this you have to solve the room modes and the bass response of the the LS50 at the same time. There are additional tools like EQ, phase, volume, crossovers and multiple subs that aides in playing at-home speaker designer, but you need be lucky and/or good to do it. I agree with hilde45 that in room measurements are way more efficient and accurate than listening. Though floor standers do not have the same latitude for adjustments as subs, you get to skip the headache of playing speaker designer and get a sound with larger scale. I state this based on my run through the subwoofer gauntlet with both REL and JL, using both small and larger speakers. I am definitely not an expert, though.   REL offers a 60-day return. If you go that route, set them up ASAP. 60 days goes by fast. 

If you stay with stand mounts, I'd suggest you can do better than the Kefs. Specifically Monitor Audio Silver 100s.