Madman! Digital vs Vinyl


Anyone out there who has a great vinyl setup and a great digital setup, try this!

Bring up Elton John’s Tumbleweed Connection Deluxe Edition on Qubuz for digital which includes Madman Across the Water and play it.

 

Then pull out your vinyl of Madman Across the Water and play it.  
 

Please tell me which sounds better on your system and what you have for TT, cartridge and phono preamp.

 

 I won’t bias the results by telling you what I think.

 

 Thanks 

dougthebiker

If an LP plays in the forest and there's no one there to hear it, does it still sound better than a CD?  Why do people continue to do these silly comparisons?  🤣

Digital has strengths - are they important to you?

Analogue has strengths - are they important to you?

There is no 'best' - but there sure is 'different'.

I ask because I‘ve got a $5k TT with a $2k cartridge on it and am trying to figure out whether it’s worth investing in a really good phono preamp or not.

Based on responses so far, I’m thinking maybe not.

 

OP:   ”I ask because I‘ve got a $5k TT with a $2k cartridge on it and am trying to figure out whether it’s worth investing in a really good phono preamp or not.”

 

This is a really important question to ask, particularly at this time. Digital is finally making strides to make parity with digital. The cost of acquiring disks, even if used is significant… while streaming is much lower ongoing cost with the benefit of a nearly infinite library. If you are future oriented, I think the answer is simple and clear… digital.
 

I have 2,000 pristine, many audiophile vinyl discs… and have experienced analog… well since born nearly 70 years ago. So I maintain and enjoy my analog end, but only 5% of the time or so since I have an equivalent digital end. If I was younger, no question I would put all my money into digital to get the best I could afford. It is now the future (as opposed to the CD promise 35 odd years ago). Splitting your money with two approaches is not going to be as effective as one.

More to discover